How to Read Trustpilot Reviews of Meal Kits

Short answer: Among the 6 meal kits we track, Trustpilot scores range from 2.6 to 4.4 with an average of 3.6 and a median of 3.7 (July 2026). Sunbasket leads at 4.4/5, while Home Chef sits lowest at 2.6/5. But a number alone is worthless without the count behind it: HelloFresh's 3.4 is backed by roughly 90,000 reviews, one of the largest samples in the category. Always read the score and the count together — and read the criticism, not just the star rating.

A Trustpilot score is often the first thing you check when you're considering a meal kit. But a number between 1 and 5 tells only a fraction of the story. Two providers can both show a similar score while one is built on a few hundred reviews and the other on tens of thousands — and that changes everything about how much you can trust the number. At the same time, the score says nothing about what people are actually praising and criticizing, and that's where the real decision lies.

In this guide, we show you how to read a meal kit's Trustpilot score correctly: what the TrustScore number actually covers, why the review count matters so much, and which praise and complaint themes keep showing up across the six providers we follow. All scores are a snapshot from July 2026 and shift continuously — so you'll also get a method you can use no matter what the numbers look like the day you check for yourself. To see how we combine the score with price, shipping, and nutrition, read about our testing methodology.

The number you see on Trustpilot is called a TrustScore and runs from 1 to 5. It's not a plain average of every star rating. Trustpilot weights reviews so newer ones count more than old ones, and profiles with few reviews get pulled toward the middle (around 3.5) until there's enough data for an accurate picture. That's why a provider with plenty of happy customers can still start out low, and why a single bad experience moves the score less the more reviews sit behind it.

Trustpilot also translates the score into a word: 4.3-5.0 = "Excellent," 3.8-4.2 = "Great," 3.0-3.7 = "Average," and below that "Poor"/"Bad." That's useful as a quick read — Sunbasket sits at 4.4 and lands in "Excellent" — but the label hides the spread. Two "average" providers can have very different patterns of satisfied and unhappy customers, and it's the spread, not the label, you should be looking for.

Here's how the field looked as of July 2026 for the providers we compare. Notice how differently sized the review bases are — that matters at least as much as the score itself.

Notice that Home Chef, one of the more established names in the category, sits at the bottom of this group. That's a reminder that popularity and rating aren't the same thing. HelloFresh, meanwhile, has the largest review base of any provider we track by a wide margin — its 3.4 is backed by roughly 90,000 reviews, which makes the number hard to argue with even though it's not the highest score in the field.

A score without context about volume is close to worthless. Sunbasket tops the field at 4.4, and its review base is sizable enough that the score holds up well under scrutiny. HelloFresh's 3.4 tells a different story: with roughly 90,000 reviews behind it, that number is about as statistically stable as a meal kit rating gets. It's a real signal that a meaningful share of a huge customer base experiences friction — typically around delivery and cancellation — even while the brand remains the category leader.

The takeaway works both ways. Don't dismiss a "lower" score if it's built on a large sample — it's not noise, it's a real read on a big population of customers. And don't over-trust a high score built on a thin sample. Rule of thumb: below a few hundred reviews, treat the score as directional; once you're into the tens of thousands, you can treat it as a genuinely reliable average. Always look at the number next to the stars before drawing a conclusion — our roundup of the most popular meal kits is a good place to see score and volume side by side.

Dig into the reviews themselves and the positive themes repeat across providers — and they tell you something about what each type of service delivers best. HelloFresh gets praised for fresh ingredients and easy recipes, while Blue Apron is credited for its classic culinary approach and recipe variety. For the more convenience-focused providers, the praise is about time: Sunbasket (4.4) is repeatedly highlighted for saving time and offering ready-to-heat options alongside its kits.

Quality and freshness are also central to the praise for Green Chef, whose customers value the USDA-certified organic ingredients and diet-specific plans (keto, vegan, gluten-free). Home Chef is regularly praised for meal variety and flexibility despite its lower overall score, and EveryPlate earns consistent praise for value — it's the most affordable option in our lineup by a clear margin. The point: a high share of positive reviews almost always clusters around a provider's core promise. Read the praise, and you can tell what a provider is actually good at — not just that it's "good."

Complaints are more consistent than praise, and that consistency is genuinely useful when you're choosing. Three themes surface again and again. Delivery is the most common: late or missed boxes come up across multiple providers — and because shipping issues are so widespread, we've covered the pattern in its own guide to meal kit shipping and delivery. Cancellation is the second theme — a recurring complaint is that the cancel button is hard to find or the flow requires a phone call, and this shows up even for well-rated providers. That shows that even a top-rated box can have a single friction point that irritates customers; if you're unsure, read how to cancel a meal kit before you commit.

The third theme is missing items and substitutions: ingredients missing from the box, or substitutions customers didn't ask for. This shows up especially in feedback about budget-tier and high-volume providers. On top of that, price comes up as a complaint again and again — even for well-rated providers like Sunbasket — and it's consistently one of the top reasons subscribers cancel meal kit subscriptions industry-wide. Notice the pattern: price gets criticized across the entire field, regardless of score. A high Trustpilot score is therefore no guarantee that you'll feel a provider is worth the money — if you want to save, look instead at the cheapest meal kits.

Trustpilot measures satisfaction — not price, not nutrition, and not sustainability. And that's exactly where the field splits sharply. On starting price per serving, the 6 providers we track range from $5.99 at EveryPlate to $13.99 at Green Chef, with an average of about $9.99. Sunbasket starts at $11.49, Blue Apron at $7.49. Notice there's no correlation between a high score and a low price: Sunbasket has both the field's best score (4.4) and a mid-range starting price, while Green Chef has one of the field's highest starting prices and a middling score. The score can't stand alone if budget matters to you — a direct price comparison does that better, and our roundup of the best meal kits weighs price, score, and content together.

The same logic applies beyond price — to things like organic sourcing, diet-specific menus, and packaging. A provider can have a solid Trustpilot score and still not be the best nutritional or sustainability fit for you, because customers are rating taste and service, not grams of vegetables per serving or packaging footprint. To dig into whether meal kits make financial sense at all, see our breakdown of whether meal kits are worth it.

Use the score as a filter, not a verdict. Follow three steps. One: always check the score and the review count together — a 4.0 built on a large sample is a stronger signal than a 4.4 built on a thin one. Two: read the most recent 1-star reviews, not just the glowing ones. They reveal whether the problems are one-off incidents or a pattern, and whether they're about something that actually matters to you. If you don't care that cancellation is a bit clunky because you plan to stay subscribed long-term, that specific criticism just isn't relevant to you.

Three: match the complaint themes to your own situation. If you live somewhere with unreliable package delivery, delivery complaints matter a lot. If you hate subscription hassle, take "hard to cancel" seriously. If you want to save money, remember that price criticism shows up across the whole field — compare price per serving and shipping directly instead. Finally, combine the score with objective numbers like price, shipping, and diet fit, exactly as we do when we test and rank the providers, so you're not deciding on reviews alone.

The Trustpilot score is a good place to start, but a bad place to stop. The number quickly tells you whether a provider is in the excellent range (Sunbasket at 4.4) or closer to average (Home Chef at 2.6). But it's the number of reviews that determines how much you can lean on that figure — and it's the themes in the text that tell you whether a provider fits you specifically.

Here's how we use them ourselves: the score is one data point among several, alongside price per serving (the field: $5.99-$13.99, average about $9.99), shipping, diet fit, and ownership structure. A provider can have a top score and still be wrong for you if the price blows your budget — and a provider with a 2.6 can be the right choice if its weaknesses are things you don't care about. Read the score, read the volume, read the criticism — and let the whole picture, not the stars alone, decide. Ready to choose? Our roundup of the best meal kits can guide you the rest of the way.